More
    HomePartner ContentTymeBank vs Paymenow: The Race to Own the South African Paycheck

    TymeBank vs Paymenow: The Race to Own the South African Paycheck

    Published on

    spot_img

    With living costs soaring past salaries, a staggering 75% of South Africans who borrow money are doing so just to buy food, according to 2024 data from Finmark Trust. This desperation has long been the territory of costly micro-lenders and predatory loan sharks, who can legally charge up to 5% interest per month plus fees, trapping low-income earners in a deepening cycle of debt.

    Now, a new breed of fintechs is muscling in on the action, armed with a model called Earned Wage Access (EWA). Instead of offering a high-interest loan, they give employees the ability to draw down a portion of the salary they’ve already earned that month. It’s a battle for a slice of the monthly payroll, and the prize is significant.


    The 10% Solution

    The concept is simple: rather than waiting until the 25th of the month, an employee can access funds they need for an emergency, like a medical bill or car repair, through an app. It’s not a loan; it’s their own money, just accessed early.
    Leading the charge are players like digital bank TymeBank, which has partnered with HR tech giant Deel’s Local Payroll platform (formerly PaySpace), and dedicated EWA specialist Paymenow. They’re finding a receptive market.

    According to Paymenow, the average user draws down around 10% of their monthly wages ahead of payday. To prevent overuse, employers typically set a cap on withdrawals, usually between 25% and 30% of an employee’s total salary.

    “We empower the employee and give them the opportunity to access the money as they earn,” says Jarred Deacon, Head of Growth at TymeBank ZA. “Instead of waiting for your payday, you can draw down when you need your money.”

    For employers, the appeal is removing the administrative headache of managing ad-hoc salary advances. “Corporates spend a lot of their time managing resources… we are inundated with requests from either lending or trying to understand how to manage people’s cash flow,” Deacon explains. The new platforms automate this process entirely.


    A Global Playbook Hits Africa

    EWA is not a new invention. It first emerged in the US in the early 2010s and has since become a mainstream employee benefit, with giants like Walmart and McDonald’s offering it. In 2022, over 7 million US workers used EWA services, transacting a total of $22bn, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

    South African startups are now localising this model, using technology to make it seamless.

    “EWA is a modern fintech product. It uses automation and API integration to streamline the underlying processes,” says Warren van Wyk, Director at Deel Local Payroll. “By using a cloud-native payroll platform such as ours, financial institutions extend EWA services to businesses and their employees. It’s fast, safe, and keeps overheads low.”

    This tech-first approach means employees can access funds via USSD menus or smartphone apps, with the fintech provider handling compliance and due diligence, not the employer.


    A Lifeline or a Crutch?

    The central question dogging the EWA industry is one of responsibility. Does providing early access to salaries fix a cash-flow problem, or does it simply mask the deeper issue of inadequate wages and encourage poor financial habits?

    Proponents argue it’s a harm-reduction tool. By providing a controlled, low-cost alternative to loan sharks, it prevents employees from falling into much more dangerous debt traps. They also point to data showing that most employees use it responsibly for emergencies, accessing relatively small sums.

    Furthermore, there’s a clear business case for employers. Financial stress is a major drain on productivity. EWA providers claim that easing this burden leads to a more focused and loyal workforce, as employees spend less time at work worrying about personal finances.

    As this new sector takes root, the competition between platforms like TymeBank and Paymenow will heat up. They are fighting not just for market share, but to define EWA as a force for financial empowerment in a country where millions are living on the edge.

    “We’ve often heard that digital innovation can democratise finance for more South Africans,” says van Wyk. “EWA is an excellent example of that promise in action.”

    Latest articles

    France’s Largest LP Bpifrance Backs Nigerian Solar-Cooling Startup Koolboks in $11M Round

    The round, a mix of debt and equity, will help the climate tech scale its PAYGO refrigerators for small businesses across Africa, tackling food waste and unreliable power grids.

    Degas’s $100m Deal: The Japanese Plan to Wire Africa’s Farms with AI and Satellites

    From Zipline to others, Africa’s breakthrough deeptechs almost always carry a touch of Japanese influence.

    Tunisia’s New Labour Law Forces a €24bn IT Hiring Giant to Quit the Country After 23 Years

    The company is pulling out of Tunisia after a new law upended its business model.

    African Startup Deal Tracker — Newest Deals

    Here’s a closer look at the notable under-the-radar investment activity we’re tracking this month.

    More like this

    France’s Largest LP Bpifrance Backs Nigerian Solar-Cooling Startup Koolboks in $11M Round

    The round, a mix of debt and equity, will help the climate tech scale its PAYGO refrigerators for small businesses across Africa, tackling food waste and unreliable power grids.

    Degas’s $100m Deal: The Japanese Plan to Wire Africa’s Farms with AI and Satellites

    From Zipline to others, Africa’s breakthrough deeptechs almost always carry a touch of Japanese influence.

    Tunisia’s New Labour Law Forces a €24bn IT Hiring Giant to Quit the Country After 23 Years

    The company is pulling out of Tunisia after a new law upended its business model.